Sunday, September 3, 2023

Overcome Evil with Good

 September 3, 2023 @ Trinity Bixby

Rev. Lucus Levy Keppel

Matthew 16:21-28, Romans 12:9-21


After spending the last week with COVID, I hope you’ll forgive me for recording this sermon, rather than delivering it in person. Early in the week, my voice did that thing where, due to the build up of fluids in my head and throat, it dropped about two and a half octaves for a while. I rarely sound like myself when that happens – instead, becoming Basso Profundo for a day or two. It’s kind of fun, but I’ve had loved ones not recognize my voice – and that can be disturbing. Still, I was reminded that the last time it happened, it was just before I went to seminary – I was working for a country music radio station in Detroit at a grand event – the Downtown Hoedown. As part of my job, I was expected to escort country musicians through Campus Martius to reach their staging area. The crowds were thick, and though my voice was deeper as a result of spending several days outside in heat, haze, and smoke, it didn’t carry as far. I found myself standing up differently – straighter, making my presence known physically instead of verbally. I’m not normally an intimidating guy, but somehow, the deep but quiet voice meant that people did, in fact get out of my way, and the way was clear for the musicians behind to follow.

It was effective, I suppose – so much so that my boss pulled me aside, and reassigned me. Apparently, I was intimidating guests to the event. No matter how effective and efficient it was to clear a path that way, in the end, it was making the experience worse for guests, and thus I had inadvertently become a stumbling block to the whole thing.

It should be no surprise, then, that I identify with Peter in Gospel of Matthew – he leaps in, full of enthusiasm, and is praised for it. Jesus gives him the nickname “Rocky” – “Cephas” in Aramaic, “Petros” in Greek – for being the first to leap to the conclusion that Jesus is the Messiah. Jesus says, “I tell you that you are Rocky. And I’ll build my church on this rock. The gates of the underworld won’t be able to stand against it.”[1] Very high praise indeed! I imagine Simon “the Rock” BarJonah felt like he was on top of the world, looking down on creation[2]! That’s when Jesus starts to talk about the traumatic and difficult future he’s facing as the Messiah, and Peter jumps right in again – “God forbid it, Lord! This won’t happen to you!”

Jesus tells Ol’ Stoneface, “Get behind me, Adversary. You are a rock that could make me stumble, for you are not thinking God’s thoughts, but human thoughts.”[3]

From being named by Jesus as the rock on which the church will be built – to being called the Adversary. All in the course of 5 verses. Now, Peter’s crashed down hard, leaving a metaphorical hole in the sand. He’s got a few options: he could dig the hole deeper, he could try to climb out on his own, or he could stay in the hole for a moment and wait to see what Jesus says next.

Fortunately, Peter chooses that moment to actually stay quiet and listen to what Jesus has to say: “All who want to come after me must say no to themselves, take up their cross, and follow me. All who want to save their lives will lose them. But all who lose their lives because of me will find them.”[4]

In this specific context – after Jesus acknowledges Simon Peter’s messianic statement, and then rebukes Peter for asking God to forbid Jesus’ death and resurrection – Jesus is making the point that Jesus is not taking the easy path, and if you’re following him, you, too, will not be taking the easy path. It would be easy to puff yourself up as a follower of Jesus – “Look at how righteous I am! Look at how holy!” but it is much harder to follow in the way that he leads us. A way of humility. Of careful care for others. Of giving your life to make the lives of many others better. Not of bold swagger, of self-aggrandizement, of prosperity and ease.

Jesus’ way is the way of love. Paul attempts to dive into the specifics of what this love looks like at many points in his letters – most strikingly in I Corinthians 13, but also in his letter to the Romans. “Love should be shown without pretending,” Paul writes, “Love each other like the members of your family. Don’t hesitate to be enthusiastic – be on fire in the Spirit as you serve the Lord!... Consider everyone as equal, and don’t think that you’re better than anyone else.”[5]

You see, in the days of the early church, the world had fallen victim to an illness of spirit – an illness of pride. It’s an illness that continues to affect us today, wherein one person may look at another, and say, “you are beneath my notice,” or, “I am better than you are.” Conversely, some people might look at another and say, “You are much better than I am, so I can do anything to you and yours to get even.” This illness goes against what God planned for us – to be loved in unique ways, but all loved nevertheless. The treatment for such an illness is not a greater separation, hatred, even war – the treatment is instead what all of us need when we are sick. Rest. Nourishment. Care.

Yes, there are times when physical isolation is necessary. But the goal isn’t to be isolated permanently – but instead to be connected spiritually even when physically separated, until the illness is past, and we can be reunited again! When Paul writes, “Don’t pay back anyone for their evil actions with evil actions of your own… but defeat evil with good,”[6] this is exactly what he’s getting at. Heaping evil upon evil just increases evil – the only way to overcome it truly is to bring goodness where there is animosity.

Just as we nurture our bodies back to health, we respond to evil with practical steps. First, we can forgive each other, offering grace without payment, just as God has offered us forgiving grace. In this way, we overcome the evil of resentment – helping to see each other as truly beloved fellow children of God. Next, we can seek reconciliation – promoting healing and peace in the community of people we know directly. This is like bringing Gatorade or noodle soup to loved ones – healing in both body and spirit. Lastly, we can continue to advocate for justice through peaceful means, just as Christ has taught us. This is a way of both improving the health of the wider community, and helps to inoculate against the illness of pride returning again. Using your voice to advocate for those whom society is determined not to listen to – that’s a powerful medicine of healing goodness.

Through it all, we pray for one another – not telling God what to do, who to save, and so on, but asking God to hold us together. In prayer, we listen for God’s call, seek the healing and forgiveness that we need, and practice offering that same healing and forgiveness to others in our lives. Sometimes, we need to step back, and realize that we’re looking at others as being better or worse than ourselves – and we need to hear God calling us back to take up the cross and follow Jesus. We may need a time of rest and recovery – or we may need to offer that time to others with grace and love. Sometimes, that insight may come from others, too – be sure to listen when others tell you that you may be taking things too far. And don’t be afraid to reach out to others in this way, too.

My friends, may you be filled with the grace of God, the love of Christ, and the healing of the Holy Spirit, overcoming evil with good in your life and in the world. Amen.



[1] Matt 16:18

[2] Inadvertent Carpenters reference.

[3] Matt 16:22-23

[4] Matt 16:24-25

[5] Rom 12 (selected)

[6] Rom 12:17, 21

No comments:

Post a Comment